Flat Fees, AUM, and Commissions, Oh My: How Financial Advisors Get Paid
Posted in :
The short version: When you hire a financial advisor, two questions about fees matter: who pays the advisor, and how the fee is calculated. On the first question there are three answers. A “fee-only” advisor is paid only by you. A “commission-only” advisor is paid through commissions on trades or product sales. A “fee-based” advisor sounds like fee-only but is paid both ways. On the second question, fee-only advisors usually charge a percentage of the money they manage for you, a flat yearly price, or an hourly rate. Wolf Pine Capital is fee-only and offers clients a choice of flat-fee or percentage-of-assets pricing.
Ask three financial advisors how they get paid and you may hear fee-only, fee-based, commission, AUM, and flat fee. The terms sound alike and mean different things. The industry has plenty of labels and very few explanations.
It helps to separate two questions. First, who pays the advisor? Second, how is the fee calculated? Most of the confusion comes from mixing them up.
Question one: who pays the advisor?
There are three common answers.
| Who pays the advisor | In plain English | |
|---|---|---|
| Fee-only | Only you | You pay a fee to the advisor. The advisor earns nothing from products you buy. |
| Commission-only | Paid through commissions on trades or product sales | You don’t pay a separate advisory fee. The advisor is paid when you buy or sell an investment, insurance policy, or annuity. |
| Fee-based | You, plus commissions on trades or product sales | You pay a fee to the advisor, and the advisor can also earn commissions. |
These three labels are the simplest way to sort the options, but not every firm uses them the same way. Ask for the details in writing.
Fee-only: you’re the only one paying
A fee-only advisor is paid by you and no one else. They don’t earn commissions on investments or insurance, and they aren’t paid more for recommending one product over another.
For CFP® professionals, this is a defined term. Under CFP Board’s rules, a CFP® professional can use “fee-only” only when neither they, their firm, nor related businesses receive sales-related compensation for their services. That covers commissions and certain referral payments.
There isn’t much more to it than that. As labels go, this one is refreshingly simple.
Keep in mind, fee-only describes how an advisor is paid. It doesn’t tell you whether they’re good at the job.
It’s also separate from being a fiduciary, which is a legal or professional duty to act in your best interest. That duty comes from federal and state securities law for registered investment advisers, and from CFP Board’s standards for CFP® professionals, not from how the advisor is paid.
Commission-only: paid through what you buy
A commission-only advisor doesn’t charge you a separate fee. They earn money from the products you buy, either when you buy or sell them or for as long as you own them. That pay can show up in a few ways:
- Sales charges on mutual funds: often called “loads.” Some funds charge one when you buy, others when you sell.
- Ongoing payments from funds: some mutual funds pay a small yearly amount, called a 12b-1 fee, out of the fund’s assets for as long as you own it. Part of it can go to whoever sold you the fund. You never see a bill, but it reduces your return.
- Trading commissions: a charge each time you buy or sell an investment.
- Insurance and annuity commissions: paid by the insurance company when you buy a policy or contract.
Here’s how a sales charge works. If you put $100,000 into a mutual fund with a 5% sales charge, $5,000 goes to the charge and $95,000 is actually invested. Easy enough, but finding the charge in the paperwork can take longer.
One clue that fund fees may be reaching your advisor: share classes. Many mutual funds come in several versions of the same fund, called share classes, each with different fees attached. If your statements show Class A or Class C shares, take a closer look, since those usually carry sales charges or ongoing 12b-1 fees. The funds aren’t inherently bad, but it’s worth knowing where the money goes.
Among advisors, trading commissions have largely given way to percentage-of-assets fees, though they still exist if you look hard enough. If your advisor calls every few weeks with a stock to buy or sell, you might have a stockbroker, whatever the business card says.
Commission-only can work well for a one-time purchase when you don’t need an ongoing relationship. Life insurance is a good example. The catch is that the agent or broker is paid only if you buy, and some products pay more than others. Ask how much they’ll earn and whether a similar option would pay them differently.
Fee-based: both
Fee-based sounds great. It also sounds almost exactly like fee-only, which is the problem. A fee-based advisor charges you a fee and can also earn commissions. CFP Board treats “fee-based” as meaning “fee and commission.”
For example, you might pay a yearly fee for advice while the advisor also earns a commission when you buy life insurance or certain funds through them. The label describes the advisor’s whole practice, so even if you never pay a commission yourself, the advisor may earn them from other clients.
Question two: how is the fee calculated?
Once you know who pays, the next question is how the fee is figured. Fee-only and fee-based advisors use the same handful of methods.
A percentage of what they manage
The most common method is a yearly percentage of the money the advisor manages for you. You’ll often see it called an AUM fee, short for assets under management. If your portfolio grows, the fee grows. If it falls, the fee falls.
Billing is simple, since the fee usually comes straight out of the account, and you and the advisor both want the account to grow. You’ve probably been blasted by the ads from a certain advisory firm stating, “We do better when you do better.” This is the billing structure they’re talking about.
Many firms that charge a percentage use tiers, which work like tax brackets. The first slice of your portfolio is charged one rate, the next slice a lower rate, and so on. Your overall rate drops as the portfolio grows, but each lower rate applies only to the dollars above its breakpoint.
Here’s the typical graduated fee schedule from Kitces Research’s 2024 study of financial planners, based on the median four-tier schedule, and what it would cost a family with $8 million in managed assets:
| Portion of the portfolio | Yearly rate | Fee on $8 million |
|---|---|---|
| First $1 million | 1.00% | $10,000 |
| Next $1.5 million (up to $2.5 million) | 0.80% | $12,000 |
| Next $2.5 million (up to $5 million) | 0.65% | $16,250 |
| Above $5 million ($3 million here) | 0.50% | $15,000 |
| Total | About 0.67% overall | $53,250 |
The family pays $53,250 a year, an overall rate of about 0.67%. The whole $8 million isn’t charged the lowest rate. At 0.50% across the board, the fee would be $40,000.
A flat fee
A flat fee is a set dollar amount for an agreed set of services, usually for a year. Some firms call it a “fixed fee.” Same thing.
You know the cost in advance, and it doesn’t swing with the market. The tradeoff is that it doesn’t drop in a down year, either.
The price is based on the work involved. Take the $8 million family from the example above. If they mostly want their investments managed, their flat fee would likely be lower than for a family with the same $8 million plus a business, stock options, trusts, estate planning, and decisions that span several generations. Under the tiered percentage fee, both families would pay the same $53,250.
That’s where a flat fee’s flexibility comes in. The scope of work can be spelled out up front, and the fee can match what you’re actually looking for, whether that’s mostly investment management or help with everything from taxes to estate planning. If your needs change, the scope and fee can be updated by agreement.
That only works if the scope is clear. Ask what’s included and what would cause the fee to change. Settle that before anyone discovers that “comprehensive” is a remarkably elastic word.
Planning only, for DIY investors
Some people enjoy picking investments and placing trades, and they see no reason to pay someone else to take over a job they like. A planning-only relationship lets them keep it. They manage the portfolio, and I help with how it fits with taxes, retirement, estate planning, and everything else, working alongside their CPA and estate attorney. It’s usually priced as a flat fee.
In my experience, planning-only clients tend to knock on the door after some sort of milestone. It might be a birthday that makes retirement feel real, a net worth number that changes the conversation, or a change in the family. Another common reason works like an insurance policy. The DIY investor says something like, “I manage the finances for our household. If I get hit by a bus, I need someone around for my spouse.”
Take the $8 million family again, and say they’ve managed their own investments for decades. Then grandchildren arrive. The portfolio hasn’t changed much, but the questions have. How do they pass wealth to the next two generations efficiently? Their estate is below the federal estate tax exemption, but they live in one of the states with its own estate tax, which can apply at much lower amounts. Now they want a plan for that too.
Decades of investing usually come with something else: large unrealized gains. That’s a good problem to have, but it adds another layer. Selling to rebalance or to fund gifts can trigger capital gains tax. Giving appreciated investments away passes the original cost, and the built-in gain, to whoever receives them. Investments inherited at death generally get a “step-up” in cost basis, which erases the built-in gain for income tax purposes. Deciding what to sell, give, or hold becomes a planning question of its own.
They don’t need someone to take over the portfolio. They need help with the decisions around it, and a backup plan in case of that crazy bus driver. That’s what planning-only is great for.
Other ways to charge
- Subscription: a monthly or quarterly payment for ongoing advice. It works much like a flat fee and is often sold in tiers. It’s a relatively new model, usually aimed at younger people who are still building wealth and have a subscription for everything.
- Retainer: an ongoing flat fee for advice. In practice, it works much like the planning-only arrangement above, but you get to tell your friends you have someone on retainer.
- Percentage of net worth: this tends to show up with high and ultra-high-net-worth families, whose balance sheets often hold a lot that can’t sit in a brokerage account, such as real estate, private investments, or a business. A similar approach, sometimes called an assets-under-advisement fee, charges a percentage of everything the advisor advises on, including assets they don’t manage.
- Percentage of income: another relatively new model, popular with HENRYs, short for “high earners, not rich yet.” Advisors who use it are serving a group the industry has historically overlooked, since many firms set minimums based on investable assets.
- Hourly: you pay for time. Good for specific questions, although some clients hesitate to call when every conversation starts a meter.
- Project fee: a set price for a defined job, such as a one-time plan.
- Performance fee: the manager takes a share of your investment gains, usually on top of a regular fee. You’ll mostly see this with hedge funds and other private investment funds. It’s rare among financial advisors, but it does exist. The classic structure is “2 and 20,” meaning a 2% yearly fee on your investment plus 20% of the gains. Because the manager shares in the gains but not the losses, it can encourage taking more risk.
Any of these can be fee-only, as long as the advisor isn’t also earning commissions. That removes one kind of conflict, not all of them. No one has yet found a way to pay an advisor that eliminates the advisor’s interest in being paid.
Putting it together
| Who pays | How the fee is calculated | Does the advisor earn commissions? |
|---|---|---|
| Fee-only | Percentage of assets, flat fee, subscription, hourly, project, and other methods | No |
| Commission-only | No separate fee; paid through trades, insurance, and fund sales | Yes |
| Fee-based | Any of the fee methods, plus commissions | Yes |
The same percentage or flat fee can show up in a fee-only or a fee-based relationship. What separates them is whether commissions are also involved.
The costs of investing still count
The advisor’s fee isn’t the only cost. Everyone who invests pays some of these, even people who manage their own money:
- Fund expenses: mutual funds and ETFs take their operating costs out of the fund each year. This yearly cost, shown as a percentage, is called the expense ratio.
- Trading costs: commissions, transaction fees, and the small gap between buying and selling prices.
- Outside managers: some advisors hire other managers for part of a portfolio, and those managers charge their own fees.
These deserve as much attention as the advisory fee, even though they’re easier to miss. You never see the expense ratio come out of your account. It’s taken behind the scenes and shows up as lower returns.
Say two advisors charge the same fee on a $2 million portfolio. One uses funds that cost an average of 0.10% a year, and the other uses funds that average 0.75%. The first portfolio pays about $2,000 a year in fund expenses and the second about $15,000. The advisory fee is the same, and the second client pays $13,000 more every year.
These costs are hard to avoid under any arrangement, but a fee-only advisor receives none of them as compensation. That leaves the advisor no financial reason to prefer the expensive fund. You still have every reason to ask why it’s there.
Why I chose fee-only
I started my career on the fee-based side of the industry. We charged clients a percentage of the assets we managed, and we also earned commissions on certain products.
One thing drove me crazy. When a client asked what they were paying us, I couldn’t give a clean answer. There was the advisory fee, plus whatever the products paid, which lived in disclosure documents most people never read. That didn’t sit right with me. If I couldn’t easily explain the bill, how was the client supposed to understand it?
There’s nothing inherently wrong with commissions. They just made the arrangement harder to see clearly, for the client and frankly for me.
When I moved to a fee-only firm, it simply made more sense. Clients paid one fee, and that was the whole of what we earned. I remember thinking, this is how I’d want my own advisor to be paid. So when I started Wolf Pine Capital, fee-only wasn’t a hard decision.
Fee-only doesn’t remove every conflict, but I think it makes the relationship more transparent, and transparency builds trust. If I’m choosing between two funds for a client, I’ll usually pick the one with the lower fee, all else being equal. All else is rarely equal, and it’s never quite that simple. But when I pick one fund over another, my clients know it isn’t because one of them pays me more.
I offer both a percentage fee and a flat fee. Some clients like the “if I make more, you make more” approach, and a fee that drops when the market does. Others prefer a known dollar amount based on the work. Either way, when a client asks what they’re paying me, I can give them one number.
Questions to ask any advisor
- Do you, your firm, or anyone connected to you earn commissions, referral fees, or other pay from products you recommend?
- How is my fee calculated, and which accounts does it include?
- What’s included, what costs extra, and what will I pay for funds, trading, or outside managers?
- How does the way you’re paid affect your advice, and how do you handle that?
- Where can I see all of this in writing? (Hint: Form ADV Part 2A, Item 5, covers fees and compensation.)
Once you know the total cost in dollars, what you’re getting for it, and who pays whom, the labels get a lot less mysterious.
You can see Wolf Pine Capital’s current options on our Fees page and read more about the services we provide.
This article is for informational purposes only and should not be considered financial, legal, or tax advice. The examples are hypothetical and omit factors that may be relevant to a particular taxpayer, including state taxes. The fee schedule shown comes from a third-party industry survey and is not Wolf Pine Capital’s fee schedule; our current fees and services are described in our Form ADV Part 2A and client agreement. Tax rules are complex and may change. Please consult your tax professional and other qualified advisors before choosing an advisor or implementing a financial-planning strategy. Wolf Pine Capital is a registered investment adviser in New Hampshire. Registration does not imply a certain level of skill or training. Wolf Pine Capital does not guarantee the accuracy or completeness of the information provided, including information from third-party sources. All investments involve risk, and past performance is no guarantee of future results.
